DUI Defense — Monroe County, PA

Updated November 2026 · 15+ years dedicated to DUI and criminal defense in the Poconos

How to challenge a breathalyzer result in Pennsylvania: for a machine that reads your breath on the spot, hold the Commonwealth to the rules in 75 Pa.C.S. § 1547(c) and 67 Pa. Code Chapter 77 — an approved device, a certified operator, at least 20 consecutive minutes of observation, two consecutive breath tests and current accuracy and calibration records. A suppressed result can still leave a general-impairment charge. Monroe County DUI lawyer Brian C. Jordan explains.

The short version:

  • The roadside test and the station test are different. The roadside test’s “sole purpose” is to help the officer decide whether to arrest (§ 1547(k)). The test after arrest is the one Chapter 77 governs.
  • You gave two samples, and the lower number is the one used. If the two results differ by .02 or more (.020 on a machine read to three decimal places), the regulation says the results are disregarded.
  • The suppression deadline comes early. A request to suppress the result goes in the omnibus pretrial motion, due within 30 days after arraignment, and a suppression issue not raised on time is ordinarily waived (Pa.R.Crim.P. 579(A), 581(B)).

A breath-test printout feels final. In Pennsylvania the Commonwealth has to show that the test was given the way the law requires before it can use the number, and those requirements leave a paper trail that a defense lawyer can check.

Which Breath Test Counts in Court?

Pennsylvania law treats the roadside breath test and the breath test after an arrest as two different things, and only one of them carries the rules this article is about.

The roadside test

Under 75 Pa.C.S. § 1547(k), an officer with “reasonable suspicion” that you are driving under the influence may require a preliminary breath test before arrest, on “a device approved by the Department of Health for this purpose.” The statute limits what that test is for: “The sole purpose of this preliminary breath test is to assist the officer in determining whether or not the person should be placed under arrest.” It also says that “No person has any right to expect or demand a preliminary breath test.”

The Department of Health’s device notice carries two separate lists. Its current version, published in the Pennsylvania Bulletin on August 29, 2026 (56 Pa.B. 5810), says officers use prearrest devices “to assist them in determining whether or not a person should be placed under arrest,” while results from approved evidential devices “will be admissible in evidence” in a DUI prosecution.

The test at the station

If you gave breath samples on a machine at the station after your arrest, that was the evidential test, and it is governed by 67 Pa. Code Chapter 77. The regulation covers “evidentiary breath test equipment used to determine the alcoholic content of the blood of persons suspected of operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol” (§ 77.21). The rules described in this article are the ones for what the regulation calls Type A equipment, a machine that analyzes your breath and gives a number at the time of the test. Chapter 77 also covers Type B equipment, which only takes a breath sample for a laboratory to analyze later and has its own section (§ 77.27).

Why police did not need a warrant

In Birchfield v. North Dakota, 579 U.S. 438 (2016), the U.S. Supreme Court held that “a breath test, but not a blood test, may be administered as a search incident to a lawful arrest for drunk driving,” and that “a warrant is not needed in this situation.” That leaves two places to look: whether the stop and arrest were lawful, since Birchfield’s rule rests on “a lawful arrest,” and whether the test followed Pennsylvania’s rules. I review the stop and the arrest along with the test; the common defenses on that side are on my Monroe County DUI defense page.

What Rules Did the Breath Test Have to Follow?

Section 1547(c) makes a breath result admissible when the test was “conducted by qualified persons using approved equipment.” Subsection (c)(1) fills in the details: breath tests “shall be performed on devices approved by the Department of Health using procedures prescribed jointly by regulations of the Departments of Health and Transportation,” and devices “shall have been calibrated and tested for accuracy within a period of time and in a manner specified by regulations of the Departments of Health and Transportation.” Those regulations are Chapter 77. Its breath-test sections were last readopted in 1990 and remain in force.

An approved device

The instrument must be one the Department of Health has approved. Chapter 77 defines Type A equipment as “Equipment approved by the Department of Health for determining the alcohol content of the blood by analysis of a person’s breath” (§ 77.22). The Department publishes its approved list as a Pennsylvania Bulletin notice and says it will revise it “semiannually”; the current list is the August 29, 2026 notice. Checking the instrument’s make and model against that list is a basic first step.

A certified operator

“Alcohol breath tests shall be conducted by a certified breath test operator” (§ 77.24(b)). Section 1547(c)(1) defines a qualified breath tester as a person who has fulfilled the training requirement “in a training program approved by the Departments of Health and Transportation,” and the course on Type A equipment must include “at least 30 hours of instruction” (§ 77.23(a)). Certification is tied to the machine. The certificate qualifies an operator “to operate only Type A alcohol breath test equipment on which they actually received instruction,” and qualifying on another model takes a course of “at least 8 hours” on it (§ 77.23(c)). So the question is not only whether the officer was certified, but whether the officer was certified on that model.

At least 20 minutes of observation

Before the first breath test, you must be “kept under observation by a police officer or certified breath test operator for at least 20 consecutive minutes,” and during that time you “may not have ingested alcoholic beverages or other fluids, regurgitated, vomited, eaten or smoked” (§ 77.24(a)). Custody may pass to another officer or certified operator during that period, “as long as the person to be tested is under observation for at least 20 consecutive minutes prior to initial administration of the alcohol breath test.” Whether those 20 minutes were kept is a question of fact, answered by the officers’ testimony and whatever reports and video exist.

How the two breath tests had to be run

The regulation requires, “at a minimum,” “Two consecutive actual breath tests, without a required waiting period between the two tests,” followed “immediately after the second actual alcohol breath test” by one simulator test, using a solution “designed to give a reading of .10%” (§ 77.24(b)). Then:

  • The lower result counts. “The lower of the two actual breath test results will be the result used for prosecution.”
  • The two results must agree. If they differ by .02 or more on a machine read to the second decimal place, or by .020 or more on one read to the third, “the test results will be disregarded,” and the device is removed from service.
  • The simulator check must land in range. On a machine read to the third decimal place, a simulator result less than .090% or greater than .109% has the same effect (less than .09% or greater than .10% on a machine read to the second decimal place).

What Records Stand Behind the Number?

Chapter 77 requires the machine to be checked on a schedule and the checks to be written down. Those records are the paper trail behind your number.

The accuracy check in the 30 days before your test

An accuracy inspection must be done “within 30 days prior to using the breath test equipment to perform an actual alcohol breath test” (§ 77.25(a)). It consists of five simulator tests with a solution designed to read .10%, and a machine that fails “shall be placed out of service” until it is serviced or repaired and retested. A passing inspection goes on a certificate of accuracy, “signed and dated by the individual who performed the accuracy inspection test” and kept for three years. The regulation calls that certificate “the presumptive evidence of accuracy referred to in 75 Pa.C.S. § 1547” (§ 77.25(c)).

The yearly calibration

The machine must also be “calibrated annually within 1 year of using the breath test equipment to perform an actual alcohol breath test” (§ 77.26(a)). Calibration is three series of five simulator tests, with solutions designed to read .10%, .05%, and a level above .10% that is a multiple of .05% (§ 77.26(b)(1)). The result goes on a signed, dated certificate of calibration, also kept for three years (§ 77.26(d)).

The simulator solution

The solution used for those checks has its own paperwork. Its manufacturer must certify its concentration, based on “gas chromatographic analysis by a laboratory independent of the manufacturer” (§ 77.24(d)). The Superior Court, however, has held that “the Commonwealth does not bear the burden of simulator solution or ampoule certification” (Commonwealth v. Starr, 1999). In November 2025 it applied that rule to reject a challenge built on the Commonwealth’s failure to introduce the solution’s certificates (Commonwealth v. Kochkodin, non-precedential).

What the certificates prove

Section 1547(c)(1) gives the machine’s paperwork real weight: “A certificate or log showing that a device was calibrated and tested for accuracy and that the device was accurate shall be presumptive evidence of those facts in every proceeding in which a violation of this title is charged.” The Superior Court has described what that covers. In Commonwealth v. Sloan (1992), in words it repeated in December 2025, the court said the certificate of calibration, offered with a certificate of accuracy, is “presumptive evidence only of the completion of the proper testing for accuracy of the breath test equipment.” The certificates speak to the machine. They say nothing about whether your 20 minutes of observation were kept, whether your operator was certified on that model, or whether your two results agreed.

When a records problem matters

The rules have consequences. The Superior Court has held that “when the statute or regulations require that a machine be taken out of service, subsequent test results will be inadmissible if rendered before ‘service, repair and adjustment, as necessary,’ occurs” (Commonwealth v. Mabrey, 1991). A mistake on a form is a different thing from a failed machine, though. In Commonwealth v. Coleman (Dec. 22, 2025, non-precedential), the calibration paperwork “contained errors that would suggest the device did not pass calibration.” The trial court believed the officer’s testimony that the machine had performed properly and the numbers had been entered wrong on the form, and it checked the figures against the machine’s own printouts. The Superior Court held the result admissible. What counts is what the records and testimony show about the machine itself.

How your lawyer gets the records

You have a statutory right to your own results: “Upon the request of the person tested, the results of any chemical test shall be made available to him or his attorney” (§ 1547(g)). The rest comes through discovery under Pa.R.Crim.P. 573. On the defense’s request, the Commonwealth must disclose requested items that are “material to the instant case,” including “any results or reports of scientific tests … that are within the possession or control of the attorney for the Commonwealth” and “any tangible objects, including documents.” Other items can be sought by motion. The court may order them disclosed on a showing that they are “material to the preparation of the defense” and that the request is reasonable; for other evidence the defense specifically identifies, the defense must also show that disclosure “would be in the interests of justice” (Rule 573(B)(2)). If the Commonwealth refuses an item, the motion is due “within 14 days after arraignment, unless the time for filing is extended by the court” (Rule 573(A)).

In a breath-test case, the records that line up with Chapter 77’s rules are:

  • the test record for your two breath tests and the simulator check;
  • the instrument’s make and model, to compare with the Department of Health list;
  • the certificate of accuracy covering the 30 days before your test;
  • the certificate of calibration covering the year;
  • the operator’s certification for that model;
  • the simulator solution’s certification;
  • anything that shows the 20-minute observation, such as reports or video.

How to Challenge a Breathalyzer Result in Pennsylvania

Two ways to raise it

A breath-test problem can reach the judge in two ways, and they run on different clocks.

A motion to suppress. A claim that the result was “obtained in violation of the defendant’s rights” is raised by a motion to suppress (Rule 581(A)). It belongs in the omnibus pretrial motion, which collects “all pretrial requests for relief” (Rule 578) and must be “filed and served within 30 days after arraignment,” unless the opportunity did not exist, the grounds were not known, or the court extends the time “for cause shown” (Rule 579(A)). A suppression issue not raised in a timely motion “shall be deemed to be waived” (Rule 581(B)); the rule’s own exceptions are that “the opportunity did not previously exist, or the interests of justice otherwise require.” Arraignment comes after the information, the formal charging document, has been filed, and it is where you are told these deadlines (Rule 571). The motion must also state “specifically and with particularity the evidence sought to be suppressed, the grounds for suppression, and the facts and events in support thereof” (Rule 581(D)), one more reason the records come first.

A challenge to the foundation. A claim that the Commonwealth cannot lay the foundation § 1547(c) and Chapter 77 require can also be raised by a motion in limine or by an objection when the result is offered at trial. Rule 578’s comment says the omnibus rule “is not intended to limit” motions in limine “which may affect the admissibility of evidence.” Both 2025 cases above were fought that way: in Kochkodin by a motion in limine and objections at trial, in Coleman by objections at a non-jury trial.

Where the challenge is heard in Monroe County

A suppression motion is made “only after a case has been returned to court,” to “the court of the county in which the prosecution is pending” (Rule 581(B), (C)). In Monroe County, a DUI case starts before a magisterial district judge, where the preliminary hearing is held, and then moves to the Court of Common Pleas of the 43rd Judicial District in Stroudsburg. That is where the breath-test challenge is decided.

Who has to prove what

At a suppression hearing, “The Commonwealth shall have the burden of going forward with the evidence and of establishing that the challenged evidence was not obtained in violation of the defendant’s rights” (Rule 581(H)). The judge then rules on whether the evidence was obtained “in violation of the defendant’s rights, or in violation of these rules or any statute” (Rule 581(I)). When the result is contested at trial instead, the Commonwealth lays its foundation through witnesses and records; in Coleman, it called the officer who gave the test and the officer who performed the accuracy and calibration checks.

The two-hour window

The blood-alcohol tiers in § 3802(a)(2), (b) and (c) measure alcohol “within two hours after” driving. A sample taken later can still prove a tier, but only under § 3802(g): the Commonwealth must show “good cause explaining why the chemical test sample could not be obtained within two hours” and establish that you “did not imbibe any alcohol or utilize a controlled substance between the time the individual was arrested and the time the sample was obtained.” The timing of your test is part of the foundation, too. How alcohol levels change in the hours after driving is covered in retrograde extrapolation in Monroe County DUI cases.

What a successful challenge does not end

If the breath result is suppressed or ruled inadmissible, the counts that depend on a number, § 3802(a)(2), (b) and (c), need some other admissible chemical-test result. The general-impairment count does not. Section 3802(a)(1) asks whether alcohol left you “incapable of safely driving,” and § 1547(f) says the chemical-testing rules do not limit “any other competent evidence bearing upon the question whether or not the defendant was under the influence of alcohol.” Driving behavior, field sobriety tests and what the officer saw can all be offered to prove that charge.

A general-impairment conviction is still a DUI conviction, and its penalties depend on your offense number and the facts. For example, § 3804(b) sentences an (a)(1) violation “where there was an accident resulting in bodily injury, serious bodily injury or death of any person or damage to a vehicle or other property” under the high-rate penalties. A successful challenge can change what the Commonwealth is able to prove. It does not by itself end the case, and no lawyer can promise how a challenge will come out.

FAQ: Breath Test Challenges in Pennsylvania

Does the roadside breath test count as evidence?

Pennsylvania treats it differently from the test at the station. Under § 1547(k), its “sole purpose” is to help the officer decide whether to arrest. The evidential test after arrest is the one that must meet Chapter 77.

How long do police have to watch you before a breath test?

At least 20 consecutive minutes immediately before the first test, by a police officer or certified breath test operator. During that time you may not have “ingested alcoholic beverages or other fluids, regurgitated, vomited, eaten or smoked” (67 Pa. Code § 77.24(a)).

Which number counts if you gave two breath samples?

The lower one (§ 77.24(b)). If the two differ by .02 or more (.020 on a machine read to the third decimal place), the regulation says the results are disregarded.

Can my lawyer get the breath machine’s calibration records?

Your lawyer can ask for them in discovery. Your own results are available on request under § 1547(g), and Rule 573 requires the Commonwealth to disclose requested items that are material to the case, including scientific test results and documents, with a motion available for anything it refuses. Certificates of accuracy and calibration must be kept for three years.

If the breath result is thrown out, is the DUI dismissed?

Not necessarily. A general-impairment charge under § 3802(a)(1) needs no number and can go forward on other evidence (§ 1547(f)).

Would refusing the breath test have been better?

No. Refusing after a DUI arrest brings a license suspension of 12 months, or 18 months with certain priors (§ 1547(b)(1)). On a general-impairment conviction, a breath-test refusal brings the penalties in § 3804(c), the subsection that also covers the highest blood-alcohol tier (§ 1547(b)(2)(ii)). And the refusal itself can be introduced at trial (§ 1547(e)).

Charged After a Breath Test in the Poconos?

A breath-test number is evidence, not a verdict, and the clock on a motion to suppress it starts at arraignment.

I have spent more than fifteen years dedicated to DUI and criminal defense, including time as a Dauphin County Assistant Public Defender. In a breath-test case, I get the records, compare them with what Chapter 77 requires, and tell you plainly what they show and what a challenge can and cannot do.

Call or text Brian directly at (570) 764-4114, 24/7, for a confidential consultation. You can also read more about DUI defense in Monroe County and DUI defense in Stroudsburg, or reach out through the contact form.


This article is general legal information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its facts. Consult a licensed Pennsylvania attorney about your situation.

Skip to content